What closing line value is
The closing line is the last price before a game starts. By then the market has taken in the news, the line-ups and the big bets, so it's the best estimate there is of the true chance.
Closing line value (CLV) compares the price you took with that final price. If you took 2.10 and the fair closing odds were 2.00, your CLV is +5.0%: you bought the bet for less than the market ended up saying it was worth.
A worked example
You took 2.10 on one side of a two-way market. Pinnacle closed at 1.95 on both sides. Those imply 51.3% each, 102.6% together, so 2.6% is margin.
With the margin removed, each side is 50%, fair odds of 2.00. Your CLV is 2.10 / 2.00 - 1 = +5.0%. Against the raw closing price of 1.95 it would look like +7.7%, which is why the margin should come out first.
Why it beats looking at results
A few dozen bets say very little about skill: the results swing too much. CLV settles on every bet, win or lose, so it shows much sooner whether you tend to get good prices.
It isn't a promise. Beating the close over hundreds of bets is the best evidence there is of an edge, but a long losing run is still possible, and bookmakers may limit accounts that keep beating the close.
Which closing odds to use
Use the sharpest bookmaker you can see, usually Pinnacle, just before kickoff. A soft bookmaker's own closing price can lag the market and makes a poor yardstick.
Enter every outcome so the margin can be removed with Shin's method, the same way Sharp Bets measures its own picks.